Book Review: Star Wars: The Force Unleashed- by Sean Williams

Star Wars: The Force Unleashed by Sean Williams
My rating: 3 of 5 stars

Having just read another video game tie-in, it was kind of obnoxious that the timeline moved me into these novels next. What is more, although that game was fun the storyline of the game was weak. (view spoiler)[The main character, Starkiller [a nice nod to Lucas's original name for Luke], goes to several planets for different missions and then ends up travelling to each of those planets again. In between his planetary travels he battles Sith ghosts or mirages or something in the destroyed Jedi temple on Coruscant to continue his training and increase his skills. In the game this makes little sense, other than because reusing an environment allows the programmers to have to do less work overall and can focus on other game-play aspects. However, because of the repeat visits to planets it makes the Universe seem small. The book feels even more formulaic as it tries to follow the video game storyline. Little new information or detail is added to the book, that isn't seen in the game already. The love-interest between Starkiller and Juno is painfully obvious to everyone except them, which makes it feel like a joke with no punchline. The only saving grace of the book is that it doesn't feature the Sith battles and multiple visits to and fights in the Jedi temple. Another small advantage of the book is that it allows us to see the motivations of some of the supporting characters like Proxy, Juno, Rahm Kota, and Bail Organa (hide spoiler)].
Having said all of that, I don't blame the book or Sean Williams for having poor source material to draw from and given what he had to work with the novel wasn't all that bad. It was also nice to finally get a resolution to what happened to Shaak Ti after George Lucas dropped both of his ideas for killing her in Episode III. If you are at all into video games, I recommend that game over the novel because they tell the same story, which ins't as true of the sequel.

View all my reviews

Book Review: Star Wars: Dark Forces: Soldier for the Empire- by William C. Dietz

Soldier for the Empire by William C. Dietz
My rating: 3 of 5 stars

This is one of the rare cases where I have not only listened to the audiobook, but have also read the print book as well. The print book has impressive illustrations that do a good job of giving tribute to the graphic novel style while still accompanying a more traditional text.
The audio adaptation is just that, it is an adaptation in the style of radio dramas without the narrator. Therefore there are a lot of times where characters are describing their actions which is kind of silly. From what I can tell the graphic novel adaptions seem to be some of the earliest "audiobooks" in the Star Wars Universe and I am grateful that as novel began to be adapted that the early decisions were for abridgment rather than radio drama style adaptations.
Being the first of three graphic novel tie-ins to a video game this book did a pretty good job of setting the scene and establishing Kyle Katarn's background and motivation.

View all my reviews

Godspeed, John Glenn.

My first post on this blog came a few days sooner than I had intended to start it, because I needed to get some things off of my chest as I tried to cope with the death of Neil Armstrong.  Now today, I mourn the passing of another Ohio astronaut and American hero, John H. Glenn, Jr.  I hurriedly prepped a slideshow presentation to accompany the lesson I plan on giving in my classes tomorrow in lieu of what we were going to cover.  What follows are images of Glenn and some highlights of his career.  I'm going to attempt to record one of the lectures tomorrow, so that I can post it for my online Earth & Space Science class as well- if I manage to do this I will update this post.




UPDATE:  What follows is a recording of one classroom lecture that I made for my online class.  Following that is a YouTube video that I had intended to play at the end of the lecture, but was unable to because I ran out of time.

Book Review: Star Wars: The Han Solo Trilogy- by A.C. Crispin

Star Wars: The Han Solo Omnibus by A.C. Crispin
My rating: 3 of 5 stars

I read these three books back-to-back and because the lines between them are a little blurred I'm going to review them all together here.  I will try to comment on each one separately, but there might be spoilers between the books.

This Han Solo trilogy, which differs from The Adventures of Han Solo trilogy by Brian Daley, introduces a young Han Solo and fills in many of the gaps left by other works.  The gap filling is nice, but also causes the books to jump around a lot and be a little sporadic because they assume you know the backstory from other places.  For example, we don't get to see a lot of Han's time in the Imperial Academy or his meeting of and bonding with Chewbacca.  Also, there are fairly large gaps of time in-between the books that make these books more like three stand-alone novels, than a coherent trilogy.  These books also mark the first time, in-Universe chronology, where we leave the comfort of modern MP3 and CD audiobooks that are unabridged to slightly abridged and enter the uncomfortable territory of really abridged cassette tape audiobooks.  The reader and audio quality went way down.  I was also surprised how much the sound effects that I loved as a teenager got in the way of following the book as an adult [although this could be because of low analog to digital conversion quality or because I listen to most audiobooks at x2 speed].  That being said, I'm going to attempt to briefly review each book individually now that I've introduced the series.

Paradise Snare:

Growing up, my library had this book, but not the two sequels, and so I listened to this one dozens (if not hundreds) of times before I ever found the other two, which I have listened to twice each.  The book explains Han's rough childhood and his escape from being a con-artist.  It also explains his affinity for, and understanding of  Shyriiwook.  From there we meet a new, temporary, furry sidekick as Han develops his piloting skills running spice instead.  There is also the first of several love interests that we see develop in the book, which serves as the driving plot for this novel and the only thread loosely holding together the whole trilogy.  Like many novels, Han's past catches up to him, but in the end [no surprise] he prevails and goes into the Imperial Academy.

The Hutt Gambit:

By the time this book starts Han has already left the Imperial Academy, and although this is discussed elsewhere, it seems like a hole in this series.  We see Chewie serving a reluctant Han, which seems to go against the personality of Han Solo that was established in the first book.  Although, yes Han is a loner, he also has deep friendships with people he has just met.  These friendships come fast, but are hard and true.  As seen with, Bria, Muuurgh, and to a lesser extent Dewlanna.  In fact, Dewlanna should be a motivator for Han to bond to Chewie.  Of course, they do come together, and pretty quickly.  The book also explores Han's joining the smuggling trade again, despite trying to flee from it several times and get his life straight, and his introduction to Lando and other familiar smuggler friends.  Through this we get to see the infamous run that led to him getting boarded and what resulted in the debt he owed to Jabba the Hutt.  The book closes on an (view spoiler)[odd little bit of rebellion and unification amongst the smuggler's as they resist the Empire at the Battle of Nar Shaddaa. (hide spoiler)]

Rebel Dawn:

The book opens with another famous scene where we get to see Han win the Millennium Falcon from Lando.  From there (view spoiler)[we see Han hook up with Bria again and begin to flirt with the Rebellion. For me this was unbelievable because it seems from the movies [although it is not explicitly forbidden] that Han is unfamiliar with and [is certainly] unsympathetic to the plight of the Rebellion (hide spoiler)].  As the story continues, we see the falling out that Lando and Han had in an event that not only wasn't Han's fault, but is hard to see how Lando could possibly interpret it another way.  As the story closes the scene is perfectly set for the actions at the Mos Eisley Cantina, even better than some of the Tales from the Mos Eisley Cantina told it.

View all my reviews

Book Review: Star Wars: Kenobi- by John Jackson Miller

Kenobi: Star Wars by John Jackson Miller
My rating: 3 of 5 stars

This book was very disappointing

Ewan McGreggor made me fall in love with Obi-Wan. I never felt that I had a connection with Alec Guinness because he wasn't around that long, and later I came to learn that he was not a huge fan of the movies that he was so instrumental in. However, when the prequel trilogy came out the first thing that really grabbed me was how much Ewan McGreggor sounded like Alec Guinness. I enjoyed his performance there, but it wasn't until the beard and the brotherly camaraderie in Episode II and III that I fell in love with McGreggor and Obi-Wan Kenobi. In fact, it was McGreggor and Portman who were among the few shining lights of the prequel trilogy. One of the most moving scenes in Episode III were when Padmé and Anakin were staring across the large distance at one another and she was crying, however much of the ethos there came from the music. The most moving scene however was Obi-Wan's speech to Anakin on Mustafar at the end of the lightsaber battle, "You were the Chosen One....You were my brother." I teared up there. And in so many other ways I loved Obi-Wan, and so I had high hopes for this book.

Those hopes were shattered. I understand Obi-Wan wanting to play down his Jedi persona in public, but even in private he seemed weak and incapable. The action of the novel revolves around local land disputes and a backwater crime/mafia group trying to establish a foothold. Obi-Wan, the compassionate and self-sacrificial Jedi, tries hard to avoid getting invovled. When he does get involved it is mostly without his lightsaber or Jedi powers, and he spends much of his time doubting himself and his actions. Certain, losing a brother-like apprentice as tragically as he did is going to cause some self-doubt and caution, but I felt that there was too much self-pity and loathing. Furthermore, (view spoiler)[I expected to see some of Qui-Gon's ghost (hide spoiler)] after his appearance in the prior book chronologically and Yoda's tease of him at the end of Episode III. But even here, without Qui-Gon's ghost, Obi-Wan still seems uncertain of himself without his former Master's help.

In the end, Obi-Wan does come up with a good plan and seems to find his footing, but I felt that it was a shame that this is the only major treatment of Obi-Wan, and in the end the last treatment of him in the Legacy's Universe and he was weak throughout.

View all my reviews

Book Review: Star Wars: Dark Lord: The Rise of Darth Vader- James Luceno

The Rise of Darth Vader by James Luceno
My rating: 3 of 5 stars

For a book that features Darth Vader and you expect it and him to be all badass- this one is a little disappointing. The book is good and delves into Vader's psyche a little bit as he struggles to come to terms with the death of Padmé, the limitations of living in a suit, and his struggle to continue to wield the Force. Also, like many books that focus on the villain, we are given a ragtag group of Jedi that survived Order 66 to cheer for. However, this sets up an inevitable dilemma- we don't like to see evil win [although personally, I think that is more realistic and am OK with it on occasion] and most books don't let the main characters, especially the good guys, die. (view spoiler)[This leads the book into the obvious conclusion of yet another Jedi surviving the extermination order and Vader's attempts to hunt and track down this individual. Like the Darth Maul books, we see the Sith antagonist weakened to the point where it is almost unbelievable, especially when we know that the Jedi were all but wiped out and Vader is given credit. I suppose that not all of the main Jedi survived and so that makes it better, but I found it hard to connect to newly introduced Jedi. (hide spoiler)] The coolest part of the book however, is that James Luceno was given the opportunity to be the one to reveal (view spoiler)[to Obi-Wan that Anakin survived and also to give us the only real appearance of Qui-Gon's ghost in the Legacy Universe (hide spoiler)]. Although, Luceno is normally masterful at weaving in other storylines, this book was a little lacking. It is a good, but incomplete, glimpse into Darth Vader and the time between movies III and IV.

View all my reviews

Book Review: Star Wars: Dark Lord: The Rise of Darth Vader- James Luceno

The Rise of Darth Vader by James Luceno
My rating: 3 of 5 stars

For a book that features Darth Vader and you expect it and him to be all badass- this one is a little disappointing. The book is good and delves into Vader's psyche a little bit as he struggles to come to terms with the death of Padmé, the limitations of living in a suit, and his struggle to continue to wield the Force. Also, like many books that focus on the villain, we are given a ragtag group of Jedi that survived Order 66 to cheer for. However, this sets up an inevitable dilemma- we don't like to see evil win [although personally, I think that is more realistic and am OK with it on occasion] and most books don't let the main characters, especially the good guys, die. (view spoiler)[This leads the book into the obvious conclusion of yet another Jedi surviving the extermination order and Vader's attempts to hunt and track down this individual. Like the Darth Maul books, we see the Sith antagonist weakened to the point where it is almost unbelievable, especially when we know that the Jedi were all but wiped out and Vader is given credit. I suppose that not all of the main Jedi survived and so that makes it better, but I found it hard to connect to newly introduced Jedi. (hide spoiler)] The coolest part of the book however, is that James Luceno was given the opportunity to be the one to reveal (view spoiler)[to Obi-Wan that Anakin survived and also to give us the only real appearance of Qui-Gon's ghost in the Legacy Universe (hide spoiler)]. Although, Luceno is normally masterful at weaving in other storylines, this book was a little lacking. It is a good, but incomplete, glimpse into Darth Vader and the time between movies III and IV.

View all my reviews